top of page
Search

The “Root Flare” Fix: Why Your Tree Looks Buried (and How to Save It)

  • Writer: Oliver Owens
    Oliver Owens
  • Nov 17, 2025
  • 6 min read

If the base of your tree looks like a telephone pole stuck in the ground—no gentle flare where the trunk widens into roots—your tree is probably buried too deep. That hidden flare (also called the root collar) is supposed to sit at or slightly above finished grade. When soil or mulch creeps up the trunk, roots can suffocate, girdle the trunk, and anchoring weakens—exactly the opposite of what we want in Florida storms. Gardening Solutions+1

visible tree roots
Quick win: Book a Tree Health Assessment. We’ll locate the real flare, check for girdling roots, and lay out a save-or-replant plan. Corrective work is performed/supervised by our Certified Arborist.

What (and where) the root flare is

The root flare is the natural widening at the base of the trunk where major roots begin. On a correctly planted tree, you can see that flare above the surrounding soil/mulch. If you can’t, the trunk base is buried. That sets up moisture against bark tissue that’s not designed to stay wet, and it can prompt roots to grow around the trunk instead of away—eventually choking the tree (girdling). CSU Engagement and Extension+1


Fast self-check: 3–4 inches out from the trunk, gently probe the top of the root ball with a screwdriver. You should meet a major root within a couple of inches—if not, the tree is likely too deep or the nursery buried the flare. (Pros do this on every planting/diagnosis.) CSU Engagement and Extension


Why buried flares cause expensive problems

  • Poor anchoring. Roots stuck in a shallow, oxygen-starved layer never establish the wide “plate” that resists wind.

  • Girdling roots. Circling roots can compress the trunk’s water/nutrient flow and create a future failure point. University of Maryland Extension

  • Decay at the crown. Constant moisture against the trunk invites rot and pests.

  • Chronic decline. Early fall color, small leaves, dieback—then the “mystery” limb failure during a summer storm.

Left alone, these issues usually get worse each year. The fix is called Root Collar Excavation (RCE)—and when done early, it’s a game changer. AirSpade Pneumatic Soil Excavation Tools


The “Root Collar Excavation” (Air-spade) fix, step by step

Root Collar Excavation (RCE) uses a tool that moves soil with compressed air (no blades), exposing the hidden flare and problem roots with minimal damage. Here’s our field process:

  1. Assessment & mapping

    We confirm the correct flare elevation, mark utilities (811 as needed), and photo-document. (Call Sunshine 811 before any digging.)

  2. Air excavation

    Using an Air-Spade/Air-Knife, we lift excess soil/mulch from around the trunk to the original grade and reveal structural roots. AirSpade Pneumatic Soil Excavation Tools

  3. Girdling-root decision

    We identify circling/crossing roots. Small ones may be pruned; larger ones require arborist judgment—removing a big girdler can destabilize or stress the tree if not staged correctly. (ANSI A300 root-management guidance applies.) west-chester.com

  4. Regrade & mulch donut

    We regrade to expose the flare and finish with a 2–4 inch mulch donut, pulled back from the trunk (no mulch touching bark). treesaregood.org

  5. Aftercare

    Gentle irrigation, no fertilizer “shock,” and a re-check in 3–6 months. If roots were significant, we may stage reductions or support work.

Translation: We put the tree back at the depth it should have had on day one, then set it up to root outward, anchor better, and breathe.

About those “mulch volcanoes” (and the right way to mulch)


Mulch volcanoes—that cone-shaped pile right up the trunk—trap moisture, invite decay, and can trigger girdling roots. The correct approach is a flat donut: 2–4 inches deep over the root zone and zero inches touching the trunk. Keep a small bare ring around the flare so you can see it. (ISA’s homeowner guide is a solid reference.) treesaregood.org


Rule of thumb: Think pizza, not traffic cone—wide and flat, with a visible “crust” (the flare).


When we recommend RCE vs. removal

  • Good candidates for RCE

    Younger to mid-age trees with decent vigor, no major trunk cracks, and buried flare from mulch buildup or deep planting. Air-spade + selective root correction often stops the slide and improves anchoring.

  • Borderline candidates

    Mature trees with large girdling roots fused to the trunk, or advanced decay where removing roots could destabilize. We may stage pruning, combine with canopy end-weight reduction, or recommend removal if risk stays high. (ANSI A300 root/risk parts inform that call.) PG&E

  • Removal recommended

    Severe trunk constriction, active lean with soil heave, extensive decay at the crown, or conflicts you can’t design around (e.g., slab expansion within the critical root zone). If that’s you, we’ll remove safely and re-plant at correct depth with a structural training plan.

Unsure which bucket you’re in? The fastest answer is a Tree Health Assessment with our arborist.

Planting (or re-planting) the right way—so you never need this fix again

If you’re putting in a new tree, start shallow and precise:

  • Find the real flare first. Remove nursery soil from the top of the ball until you see flare; don’t assume the top of the container is correct. tense-deer.files.svdcdn.com

  • Set the depth. Place the flare at or slightly above finished grade (higher in poorly drained sites). Gardening Solutions

  • Go wide, not deep. The hole should be 2–3× wider than the root ball and no deeper than the ball from flare to bottom; roughen sides so roots don’t skate. UMass Amherst

  • Fix circling roots before backfill. Cut/straighten container “J” roots so they grow outward, not around the trunk. University of Maryland Extension

  • Mulch donut, not volcano. 2–4″ deep; no mulch against bark. treesaregood.org

Prefer a simple checklist PDF? We can supply one or you can use university guides we’ve linked below.


What improvement should you expect after a proper RCE?

  • Stability: visible flare and outward-growing structural roots = better anchoring in wind.

  • Vigor: improved oxygen exchange at the crown and fewer wet-bark problems.

  • Fewer mystery diebacks: relief from trunk compression where girdlers were removed (when safe to do so).

  • Easier inspections: you and insurers/HOAs can see correct depth instantly.


Case examples (Tampa Bay area)

  • Seffner live oak: Volcano-mulched for years; no flare visible. We air-excavated, exposed a 4″ girdling root, removed two small girdlers, left one large root to stage later, and re-graded with a proper mulch donut. Follow-up pruning reduced end-weight over the roof. The tree greened up and rode out summer storms without issues.

  • Valrico crape myrtle: Buried 3″ too deep from the nursery—constant dieback. We lifted the flare, severed container “J” roots, and reset grade. Two months later: strong flush, no suckering at the base.

  • Brandon laurel oak: Severe trunk constriction from a large girdler; cavity at the crown. RCE confirmed structural loss; we recommended removal and replanted a right-size species at correct depth with a light structural training schedule.


FAQs


Can I just pull the mulch back and call it a day?

It helps, but buried trees usually need soil removal down to the flare and a look at structural/girdling roots. That’s what RCE does safely.


Is air-spade safe for roots?

Yes—air excavation moves soil, not wood. It’s the industry standard for exposing root collars with minimal injury when performed by pros. AirSpade Pneumatic Soil Excavation Tools


Will cutting a big girdling root kill my tree?

It depends. Removing a large girdler can destabilize or shock the tree if there isn’t enough compensating root structure. We follow ANSI A300 root-management guidance and may stage work. west-chester.com


How deep should my mulch be after the fix?

2–4 inches, pulled back from the trunk so bark can dry and the flare stays visible. treesaregood.org


I’m planting new. How high should I set it?

With the flare at or slightly above grade (a bit higher in poorly drained sites). Don’t dig the hole deeper than the ball; if you go too deep, backfill and firm the base before setting the tree. Gardening Solutions+1


Your next steps (simple + zero pressure)

  1. Diagnose — Schedule a Tree Health Assessment. We’ll locate the root flare, check depth, probe for girdling roots, and photograph for your records.

  2. Correct — If you’re a candidate, we’ll perform Root Collar Excavation with air tools, prune minor girdlers (when appropriate), and finish with the right mulch donut under Certified Arborist oversight. west-chester.com

  3. Prevent — Plant or re-plant at correct depth and set a light structural-pruning schedule so small stays small.


Free authoritative resources (link these at the end of your post)

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page